Turning Methane Into Methanol: How Scientists Are Taking Inspiration From Nature To Solve A Chemical Engineering Challenge
Methane is best known as the main ingredient in natural gas. It is also a potent greenhouse gas, and finding ways to use it more efficiently - rather than allowing it to escape into the atmosphere - is an ongoing challenge.
Now, researchers have developed a new catalyst, inspired by the way methane-eating bacteria work, that could offer a different approach to converting methane into methanol, an important industrial chemical.
Methanol is used to manufacture everything from plastics, paints and adhesives to fuels and pharmaceuticals. It is also a useful chemical building block for producing a wide range of other materials.
The challenge is that methane is remarkably difficult to convert directly into methanol. Its molecular structure is extremely stable, requiring considerable energy to break the chemical bonds holding it together.
There is another complication. Methanol is itself quite reactive. Once methanol is formed, it can continue reacting with oxygen, eventually breaking down into carbon dioxide and other unwanted products.
Getting the reaction to stop at precisely the right point is one of the biggest challenges in methane chemistry.
Taking a cue from nature
In nature, certain bacteria have evolved an efficient way to deal with this problem. Known as methane-eating bacteria, or methanotrophs, they consume methane as an energy and carbon source.
They do this using specialised biological molecules called enzymes, which act as catalysts. These enzymes contain metal atoms, including iron or copper, that help trigger the chemical reactions needed to convert methane into methanol.
The Monash research team has taken inspiration from one of these enzymes, soluble methane monooxygenase, which uses iron at its active site.
Rather than attempting to reproduce the enzyme itself, the researchers have developed a synthetic material inspired by selected features of the enzyme’s iron coordination environment.
The material, known as a nanozyme, combines iron with naturally occurring amino acids and a porous mineral called zeolite Y.
Think of zeolite as a microscopic scaffold, with a network of tiny pores that can accommodate and support the other ingredients. The amino acids help modify the local coordination environment surrounding the iron atoms, influencing how their catalytic behaviour and how effectively they drive the reaction.
This local environment is important. The researchers' premise is that controlling the immediate surroundings of the iron can influence its ability to activate methane and promote selective methanol formation while limiting the unwanted oxidation reactions.
Why controlling the reaction matters
The research team - led by Dr Priya Samudrala of Monash Chemical and Biological Engineering (CBE) - includes PhD candidate Harshita Harshita of CBE; Professor Murali Sastry of CBE and Monash Materials Science and Engineering (MSE); and Dr Ranjith Kumar Jakku of RMIT and MSE.
The team experimented with different combinations of iron and amino acids, including histidine, glutamate and aspartate, to establish how the catalyst's composition influenced its performance.
They then tested the material under different reaction conditions, including variations in temperature, pressure and the amount of oxidising agent used.
Under optimised laboratory conditions, the catalyst produced up to 99 micromoles of methanol per gram of catalyst per hour at 70°C, with 95% selectivity for methanol among the quantified liquid oxygen-containing products. In simple terms, methanol accounted for 95% of those measured products, an encouraging result for a reaction where unwanted oxidation is a major obstacle.
While these findings highlight the potential of the catalyst design, improving the overall conversion of methane into methanol remains an important focus for future research.
What could this mean for industry?
Today, most industrial methanol production from natural gas involves an indirect process. Methane is first converted into a mixture of gases known as synthesis gas, or syngas, before being processed further into methanol. These processes typically require high temperatures and substantial infrastructure.
A successful direct conversion process could eventually reduce the number of processing steps and potentially make smaller or more remote methane resources economically useful.
This is particularly relevant to stranded gas - natural gas deposits that are difficult or uneconomic to transport to existing processing facilities.
There is also a potential environmental benefit. Methane has a much greater warming effect than carbon dioxide over a 100-year period. Finding practical ways to capture and use methane could therefore potentially contribute to emissions reduction efforts, depending on the overall environmental impact of the process.
But there is still considerable work to do. The process needs further development to improve the amount of methane converted into methanol, reduce reliance on chemical oxidants and establish whether the catalyst can operate efficiently at an industrial scale.
Engineering chemistry at the molecular level
The research, published in ChemCatChem, illustrates how insights from biology can inform the design of new materials for industrial chemistry.
Rather than simply using iron as a catalyst, the researchers have shown how engineering the coordination environment around iron can influence catalytic performance – drawing on the sophisticated chemistry that has evolved in nature.
It is an early-stage result, rather than a ready-made industrial solution. But understanding how to control chemical reactions at this level could help researchers develop more selective catalysts for methane conversion and other challenging industrial processes.
Sometimes, the answer to an engineering problem starts with understanding how nature has already solved part of it.
Source: Monash University